PPF vs Mutual Fund: Key Differences?

Investors in our country enjoy an abundance of investment options, but among them, the Public Provident Fund (PPF) and mutual funds stand out as the most popular. While PPF is a product designed by the government which offers guaranteed returns and attractive tax benefits, mutual funds are market-linked investment vehicles offered by AMCs and managed by professional fund managers. Both options have their unique features, and they are suitable for different types of investors. Let’s take a look at PPF Vs Mutual Fund in detail, and Compare PPF and Mutual Fund to understand which option would be better for you.

What is a Public Provident Fund?

The Public Provident Fund was introduced in 1968 by the National Savings Institute of the Ministry of Finance. Over the years, it has cemented its place as one of the most popular and trustworthy investment options available to Indian citizens, due to the fact that it’s a government scheme and that it offers guaranteed and tax-free returns. For this reason, the Public Provident Fund is favoured by conservative investors looking for steady returns.

Here are some features of PPF:

1. It is one of the safest investment options available in India as it is backed by the Government. They guarantee the returns and principal amount to investors.
2. PPF returns are announced by the Government every quarter. There is generally some minor variation due to policy changes, but it tends to stay steady throughout the year. As of the second quarter of the financial year 2024/25, the government offers an interest rate of 7.1% on PPF investments.
3. Over its tenure, the returns get compounded annually.
4. The PPF comes with a lock-in period of 15 years, but the government allows partial withdrawals after you complete the fifth year. After the maturity period, one can renew their PPF account for an additional 5 years.
5. Another aspect that makes PPF so attractive to investors is the tax benefits it offers. Section 80C of the Income Tax Act allows investors to claim a deduction up to a limit of Rs. 1.5 lakh per year. This means whatever amount you invest in PPF during the year gets deducted from your total taxable income, thus reducing your tax liability.
6. The tax benefits of PPF don’t end there! Not only is the amount you invest free of tax, but also the interest earned and the maturity amount. This gives PPF the Exempt Exempt Exempt status and makes it one of the most tax-efficient options in the country.
7. One can start investing in PPF from as low as Rs. 500. There is, however, a limit to how much one can invest, which is capped at Rs. 1.5 lakh per year. You can make these payments in instalments (a maximum of 12 instalments in a year) or invest a lump sum amount.
8. PPF allows investors to take a loan against their balance between the 3rd and 6th years after opening the account.

What is a Mutual Fund?

While PPF is a scheme, mutual funds are investment vehicles. This makes mutual funds more diverse, flexible, and dynamic compared to PPF. Asset Management Companies (AMCs) handle the administration of mutual funds, and as of 2024, there are over 40 AMCs operating in India, each offering a variety of different schemes.

These schemes pool money from multiple investors, and the fund is then invested in a variety of assets across a wide range of industries by professional fund managers. Every investment decision in a particular mutual fund is taken by the professional fund manager, who has a team of expert analysts and researchers to support their decisions.

The diversity in mutual funds comes from the ability to invest across different asset classes, such as equities, bonds, and money market instruments. There are many categories of mutual funds, but for the sake of ease we’ll divide them into three:

1. Equity Mutual Funds

These types of mutual funds invest primarily in stocks. Due to the risky nature of stock investing, equity mutual funds are considered high risk compared to other types of mutual funds. However, with high risk comes high reward. Equity mutual funds offer the highest returns among mutual fund types, thanks to their exposure to the growth of individual stocks and market sectors. It’s important to note that over the long term, the risks associated with these funds are reduced as markets tend to grow and recover from short-term volatility. An example of an equity mutual fund is the Equity-Linked Savings Scheme (ELSS).

2. Debt Mutual Funds

These funds invest mainly in fixed-income securities such as bonds, government securities, T-bills, Certificates of Deposits, and Commercial Papers. They are considered the safest category of mutual funds due to the predictable nature of their returns. This makes them suitable for conservative investors looking for steady returns. Liquid funds are an example of debt mutual funds.

3. Hybrid Mutual Funds

As the name suggests, hybrid mutual funds combine the elements of equity and debt. For example, a hybrid fund may allocate 60% to equity and 40% to debt, or vice versa, or even maintain a 50/50 balance between the two. This makes hybrid funds suited for investors looking to take a balanced approach to earn moderate returns. A balanced advantage fund is an example of a hybrid mutual fund.

Mutual funds are considered attractive to a broader spectrum of investors compared to PPF. Here are some features of mutual funds:

1. One of the biggest benefits offered by mutual funds is diversification. Every rupee you invest in a fund is spread across a wide range of assets. For example, if you want to build a portfolio through stock investing, you’ll have to select each stock carefully and invest in multiple companies to achieve diversification. But when you invest in a mutual fund, your money is automatically distributed across many different assets and industries. This built-in diversification helps to reduce risk, as the performance of your investment is not tied to the success or failure of any single stock.
2. The next biggest feature is professional management. Your money is handled by expert fund managers who have an entire team of qualified researchers and analysts at their disposal. You get to benefit from their experience and knowledge without needing to actively manage your investments yourself.
3. Mutual funds may or may not come with a lock-in period. For example, ELSS comes with a lock-in period of three years, so it offers low liquidity. Mutual funds without lock-in offer high liquidity, and your units can be redeemed within 24 hours.
4. Like the PPF, mutual funds offer investors two ways to contribute – the first is lump sum, and the second is called SIP (Systematic Investment Plan). Through SIP, investors can contribute a fixed amount regularly, like monthly or quarterly. The amount gets deducted from the linked bank account automatically on the predetermined date. SIPs are a disciplined way to invest and have many benefits of their own, such as rupee cost averaging.
5. Mutual funds don’t offer as many tax benefits as PPF. An exception to this is ELSS, which allows investors to claim a maximum deduction of Rs. 1.5 lakh under Section 80C. Any profits made through mutual funds are also subject to capital gains tax.
6. One can use mutual funds to achieve a variety of financial goals. For example, short-term goals such as building an emergency fund can be achieved through liquid funds, as it helps preserve capital. On the other hand, equity mutual funds can help you achieve long-term goals like building a retirement corpus, as they allow capital appreciation.

Key Differences Between PPF and Mutual Funds

Factor	Public Provident Fund	Mutual Funds
Type of Investment	PPF is a government-backed scheme that pays a fixed interest.	Mutual funds are run by Asset Management Companies and offer market-linked returns.
Returns	PPF offers guaranteed, but moderate returns which are annually compounded. The government announces changes to the returns every quarter.	Mutual fund returns are market-linked and depend on the nature of the mutual fund. For example, equity funds offer higher returns compared to hybrid funds, and hybrid funds offer better returns than debt funds.
Risks	The Government of India runs the PPF, so there is no risk involved with this investment.	The risk is variable, and it depends on the category of mutual fund. For example, equity funds carry significant short-term risks compared to hybrid funds. Debt funds are even more secure than hybrid funds, but they are not entirely risk-free.
Tenure	PPF has a fixed tenure of 15 years, but it can be extended after maturity in chunks of five years.	Some mutual fund schemes have a fixed tenure, but most are flexible.
Lock-in Period	Investment is locked in for 15 years, but the government allows you to partially withdraw from the fund after the end of the fifth year.	A mutual fund may or may not have a lock-in period. For example, ELSS investments are locked in for three years.
Liquidity	Since there is a lock-in of at least six years, PPF doesn’t offer high liquidity.	Most mutual funds are highly liquid and allow you to redeem units within 1 or 2 business days.
Taxation	PPF comes in the Exempt Exempt Exempt category of investments, meaning the amount you invest, the interest you earn, as well as the maturity amount are all tax-free.	Gains made from mutual funds are considered capital gains and taxed accordingly. The exact LTCG and STCG vary from fund category to fund category. However, ELSS does provide investors some tax relief under Section 80C, by allowing them to claim a deduction of Rs. 1.5 lakh every year.
Market Influence	PPF is not influenced by market fluctuations.	Mutual fund returns depend on how the market is performing.
Contribution Limit	One can only invest up to Rs. 1.5 lakh a year in PPF.	There is no upper limit to investing in a mutual fund.
Management	PPF is self-managed.	Professional fund managers manage mutual funds.
Diversification	Most of the investment is made in government fixed-income products, so it doesn’t offer the benefit of diversification.	Mutual funds are highly diversified as they invest in a variety of assets such as stocks, bonds, CPs, CDs, T-Bills, and more.
FInancial Goals	PPF is good for achieving long-term goals, such as retirement planning.	Mutual funds offer flexibility and can be used to achieve short-, medium-, and long-term financial goals.
Investor Appeal	PPF is suitable for conservative investors looking for steady returns, and also for those looking to be tax-efficient.	The sheer variety of mutual funds makes them suitable for a very wide range of investors.

PPF vs Mutual Fund: Which is Better for Your Investment?

As you can see, both PPF and mutual funds are distinct options, each with its own set of pros and cons. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on your financial goals, risk profile, and investment horizon. For example, if you are someone who is looking for a tax-efficient option offering guaranteed, but modest returns, PPF would be suitable for you.

On the other hand, if you are willing to take on some risk to earn higher returns, and want to enjoy benefits such as diversification and professional management, mutual funds would be more suitable for you. Even conservative investors can invest in mutual funds by going for less risky options like debt mutual funds. That’s the beauty of mutual funds – the sheer variety of options they offer means there is something for every investor. 

Conclusion

And there we have it! You know what the Public Provident Fund and mutual funds are, and you are aware of all that separates the two. While PPF is a safe and tax-efficient option, mutual funds offer diversification and professional management. From low-risk debt funds to high-risk equity funds, mutual funds offer a variety that caters to investors with varying risk tolerance. While PPF is a good long-term option, it is limited by the Rs. 1.5 lakh upper limit set by the government. On the other hand, mutual funds have no upper limit and can help you achieve short-, medium-, and long-term financial goals.

The decision between the two depends on your financial situation, investment goals, and risk tolerance. Generally, mutual funds are considered the better option due to their higher return potential, many investors aim to take a balanced approach and invest in both PPF as well as mutual funds. PPF offers stability and tax benefits, while exposure to equity helps investors reap higher rewards. However, as rewarding as mutual fund investing is, you can greatly benefit from consulting with a mutual fund advisor.

A certified professional can assess your financial situation and help you sift through the mountain of mutual fund schemes available to us. They can help you make informed decisions by making you aware of the tax implications, and fees associated with your investments. They can recommend suitable schemes by analysing various risk-adjusted ratios, such as the Sharpe ratio, beta, and alpha, to ensure that your investments align with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Start your mutual fund journey today!